• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

People Equation

Leadership Development and Career Success Tips

  • About
  • Services
    • Life Story Coaching
    • Business Writing
  • Portfolio
  • Blog
  • Contact

Book Review: The Sharp Employee

by Jennifer V. Miller

In preparation for reviewing the Marcus Buckingham’s soon-to-be released book Find Your Strongest Life, I decided to pull some of Buckingham’s earlier books off the shelf and give them a second look.  This review is the first of a three-part series.

Now, Discover Your Strengths

Marcus Buckingham and Donald O. Clifton

The highlights:

In the follow-up to the best-selling book First, Break All the Rules, Buckingham settled into the key theme for many of his subsequent books: how to leverage one’s strengths. The premise of this book is that most organizations have the people equation backwards: they select, train, develop and measure their employees based on pre-determined, uniform standards like competencies and performance requirements. 

Buckingham and Clifton assert that organizations need to reverse the order of this equation. Rather than form-fitting people to an existing standard they need to identify employees’ strongest threads, reinforce them with practice and learning and help them carve out a role that draws on their strengths. The authors’ research leads them to believe that organizations’ inherent focus on “fixing” weaknesses (rather than building strengths) tends to create “well-rounded” employees.  That is, they are marginally good at many things, but not excellent at any.  By contrast, “strengths-based” companies have people who are “sharp”—defined by their spikes of talent.

 The book is divided into three sections:

  •  Defining “what is a strength?”—which is seen as a combination of innate talent, knowledge and skills
  •  Discovering one’s greatest strengths—as measured by 34 “themes” in an online StrengthsFinder profile, which is included in the purchase of the book
  •  Putting one’s strengths to work—both for the individual and for managers wanting to develop their employees’ strengths

Jen’s Take:

In theory, I agree that focusing on one’s strengths make sense.  In practice, however, most companies (especially large ones) are wired for conformity. This makes the concept of creating highly personalized development plans a challenge at best and completely impossible at worst.  Plus, I think that developing competencies can help leaders get clear about the performance they need to be rewarding in their employees.  My preference is to advocate for a “both” approach rather than either/or—work within the company’s need to have structure, yet find a way to capitalize on employees’ strengths, while minimizing their weaknesses.

 

Best for: managers looking to find a way to energize their employees; individual contributors who are seeking direction in what their hidden talents are

 

Take a pass: managers who work in highly structured organizations; the book’s recommendations may be frustrating.

Sep 18 2009 · Categorized: Book Review, Leadership, Personal Effectiveness, Team Effectiveness · Tagged: Leadership, Management, Supervisory Skills, Team Effectiveness

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Master the people equation.
Elevate your leadership.

Tips for how to make the most of interactions with your boss, peers and colleagues; show up in a way that’s positive and respectful.

Topics

  • Bad Boss Diaries
  • Book Review
  • Business Management
  • Communication
  • Food for Thought Friday
  • Guest Blogger
  • Human Resources
  • Leadership
  • Learning
  • Office Politics
  • Personal Effectiveness
  • Social Media
  • Team Effectiveness
  • Training Delivery
  • Weekend Reflections
  • Workplace Issues
  • Zen of Jen

The People Equation blog by Jennifer V. Miller is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 United States License.

Footer

Follow the People Equation

  • LinkedIn
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclosure Statement
  • What’s with the llamas?

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Sign Up

Copyright © 2025 · People Equation